In "Bad City," Times investigative reporter Paul Pringle who led the paper's efforts to scrutinize Puliafito and USC dissects how the university and several of The Times . The blankets, she said, were not covering his face. A rumpled Puliafito answered the door. Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. (2005). It is a myth, it is an invention, and it is, frankly, pathetic that five years after the story was published with all this going on in the world, were still talking about this.. He won the 2019 Pulitzer Prize for investigative reporting with colleagues Harriet Ryan and Paul Pringle and was part of the team of reporters that won a Pulitzer Prize for its coverage of the San Bernardino terrorist attack. From 2001 to 2007 he was director of the Bascom Palmer Eye Institute of the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine. She admitted to using methamphetamine twice since giving birth and one time being the night before the infant died, according to an email by the coroners investigator. When Pringle wrote the first version of the Puliafito story, he had not been able to find the young woman who had overdosed at Hotel Constance. There was conversation about the childs death, Davis said, declining to elaborate. Yoder said she woke just before 7:30 a.m. to find the boy unresponsive, the report states. Tulare sheriff said a drug cartel, then backtracks, These are the 101 best restaurants in Los Angeles, California vs. Florida: A tale of two Americas, Prosecutors sought 33 years to life, but Mongols biker who killed cop may be freed by March, Disneyland cast members laughed before disabled woman was injured on ride, lawsuit alleges, Five ways you can use Shape Your L.A., The Times civic engagement tool, Plane crash near Modesto airport leaves one dead, Essay: Martin Luther King Day should make you uncomfortable. Editors are supposed to make certain that reporters knock on those doors if all other attempts to reach the subject failed., Duvoisin said he thought Pringles efforts to contact Nikias were a bit over the top and verging on harassment. But, he said, I did not try to prevent him., Pringle countered that characterization: It could not be more routine to knock on the door of the subject of a story when that person does not respond to phone calls, emails and other attempts to engage him., He said he would expect to be disciplined by an editor if I failed to do that on a story of such importance., When Pringle went to Nikias house, the university president wasnt there. (Credit: Irfan Khan / Los Angeles Times) Read Less Local News And journalism prevailed.. As detectives worked, a blood sample taken from Boazs heart awaited testing in the lab of the L.A. County medical examiner-coroner. The specialist in child-death prosecutions, who led the case against the killers of Gabriel Fernandez, wrote: Later on, Yoder breastfed the victim. Matt Hamilton is a reporter for the Los Angeles Times. Youre basically taking the evidence away from the victims, Jackson said. There are a lot of unanswered questions about this death, said Dr. James Ribe, a specialist in pediatric autopsies who retired from the L.A. County coroners office in 2018. They found a map to that world in the County Jails pay phones. Without that, the prosecutor and the detectives concluded they could not take the investigation further. Carmen Puliafito resigned in March 2016 as dean of the Keck School of Medicine of USC. The now-former dean of the University of Southern California's Keck School of Medicine routinely partied hard with a band of drug users which included a 21-year-old prostitute and a troubled karaoke deejay with a lengthy rap sheet. Ocular Surgery News | From early in his life, Carmen Puliafito, MD, MBA, began to emerge as a leader. The agreement was reached four months after a Times investigation disclosed Puliafitos relationship with Warren and a circle of other young addicts and criminals. 173.212.230.148 Geragos and a member of his firm who signed the November stipulation declined to answer questions about the settlement terms. Former L.A. coroners investigator Denise Bertone, a nurse who performed more than 2,000 pediatric death investigations, said she doubted whether Yoder was credible enough to inform the coroners determination. Warren later bends over lines of white powder on a tray. The apartment lease was in his name, and her family and friends suspected he paid for almost everything: furniture, groceries, baby supplies and, disturbingly, drugs. A coroners spokeswoman acknowledged that the marks could be evidence of a face-down death but said they were consistent with blanket suffocation. Cloudflare Ray ID: 78bba401eaef915f Then, in mid-October, she told them Boaz had died of SIDS. He said that the mother was his girlfriend but that he was in Pasadena. Independent, local . Paul Pringle is a Los Angeles Times reporter who specializes in investigating corruption. As cynical as Ive been for a long time, it stunned me. Managing Editor Marc Duvoisin and publisher and Editor-in-Chief Davan Maharaj were fired in 2017. They called the Sheriffs Department, reiterated their concerns about Puliafito and encouraged investigators to look closer at Boazs death. Although USCs flaws have been exposed, The Times largely have not. The family of a woman who had a drug-fueled relationship with former USC medical school dean Carmen Puliafito received $1.5 million to head off a lawsuit. Detectives went to Puliafitos home, but he declined to talk and referred them to a criminal defense attorney. Duvoisin and Maharaj both dispute how the team was formed and that it worked even briefly without their knowledge. Neither man has read Bad City. When told of allegations made in the book, they vociferously denied them. Yoder gave birth last year to a second child, a girl, with Franko, according to birth . The reporting team handed in the next draft of the story at the end of March 2017. Thats a circumstance that calls for the greatest precision, care, evenhandedness, concern for accuracy, concern not to overreach.. He was just found like this by his parents?. Puliafito denied an ongoing relationship with Voigt and said he had never heard of the women. USC paid former Keck School of Medicine dean Carmen Puliafito over $1.8 million following his termination from the University, according to University tax filings disclosed this week. On Aug. 21, 2017, Justin Dearborn chief executive of the Times parent company, which at that point was called Tronc announced that Maharaj and Duvoisin had left the paper, along with several others. Mike Davis and Gene Morse into a murky world of desperate young addicts and small-time drug dealers with a disgraced multimillionaire at the center: Dr. Carmen Puliafito, former dean of USCs Keck School of Medicine. We were investigating a criminal case, and if there was evidence of said criminal activity we were investigating, I definitely would have been interested in seeing it.. Gen. Rebecca Smith asked. Lucas, the head coroner, reiterated confidence in Szymanski in an email to The Times this month. The detectives soon discovered that Yoder and Puliafito had been on the Sheriffs Departments radar well before Boazs death. Carmen Puliafito is shown on the first day of a 2018 state medical board trial where he said he'd completely rehabilitated from drug use. Puliafito didnt call 911. He was, his lawyer noted, one of the foremost ophthalmologists in the world. The physician, whose license was suspended in September 2017, promised that if he was allowed to practice again, he would devote himself to treating the underserved Latino population in East L.A. On the witness stand at a hearing in June 2018, nine months after Boazs death, Puliafito portrayed himself as completely rehabilitated and said he hadnt used drugs in almost a year. This was after [the attorney] had already signed off on it., Duvoisin defends all his editing decisions on the Puliafito story. LOS ANGELES, CA Former USC Keck School of Medicine Dean Carmen Puliafito is officially without a medical license Tuesday. In total, Puliafito was compensated more than $1.8 million when his base salary and bonus were factored in. Carmen A. Puliafito is an opthamologist and is the former Dean of the University of Southern California Medical School. His drug use continued even after Warren overdosed in his presence in a Pasadena hotel room and he was forced from his deans post in March 2016. [12] In 2012, Fujimoto, Swanson, and David Huang, with Puliafito and Joel Schuman, received an Antnio Champalimaud Vision Award from the Champalimaud Foundation. Two months after the infants death, a toxicology screen detected methamphetamine. Deputy Dist. In USCs lecture halls, labs and executive offices, Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito was a towering figure. In the case of the newborn, Boaz Yoder, Puliafito paid the rent on Dora Yoders Altadena duplex, where the baby died. [5] Before that, he had been director of the Bascom Palmer Eye Institute of the Leonard M. Miller School of Medicine, and chair of the department of ophthalmology. Sarah Warren, left, and Carmen Puliafito. Family members received prewritten affidavits to sign containing explicit denials that Puliafito used drugs as well as denials that Yoder harmed the baby. Faculty and staff at the University of Southern California complained about Dr. Carmen Puliafito's worrisome behavior for years leading up to his public ousting amid accusations of illicit drug use and solicitation while dean of the Keck School of Medicine, according to an ongoing Los Angeles Times investigation.. Current and former university employees, as well as documented letters of . She said she immediately called Ariel Franko, the childs father. According to Bad City, she began waiting tables and hoped to go to college. Yoder claimed she phoned for an ambulance at 7:30 a.m. Law enforcement records do not reflect such a call. Then-USC Keck School of Medicine Dean Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito arrives at the Second-Annual Rebels With A Cause Gala at Paramount Studios on March 20, 2014, in Puliafito had three Ivy League diplomas. Six months after Dr. Carmen Puliafito stepped down as dean of USC's medical school, he was called by the university to give sworn testimony as a witness in a lawsuit the institution was facing. There was nothing out of the ordinary there, he said. Photos, videos emerge of drug parties with Carmen Puliafito, who chaired the University of Miami's Bascom Palmer Eye Institute from 2001-2007. Carmen Anthony Puliafito (born 1951)[1] was an American ophthalmologist and academic administrator. It provided proof that more had been going on in the Altadena home when Boaz died than Yoder had let on. The closer investigators from the L.A. County Sheriffs Departments Homicide Bureau looked, however, the more doubts they had. She and Lucas met. The death of a newborn named Boaz Yoder in an Altadena apartment seemed at first glance like a case of sudden infant death syndrome. Sarah Warren and her family left Southern California and moved to Texas. She checked a box indicating accident.. [3] He completed a residency in ophthalmology and a fellowship in vitreoretinal surgery at the Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary. Managing Editor Marc Duvoisin and publisher and Editor-in-Chief Davan Maharaj were . I dont know. He perjured himself on the stand here today, the prosecutor declared. Cookie Duration Description; cuid: 2 years: This cookie is set by the provider Curalate. But under their leadership, Pringle wrote, a balance of power that existed between USC and the Times for generations had been subverted so that it had become tilted in USCs favor.. In 2017, USC terminated former Keck Dean Carmen Puliafito following drug use, on-campus partying and keeping company with criminals. The sources said the negotiations by lawyers for the Warrens, USC and Puliafito also took place around the time law enforcement was looking into Puliafitos drug use and whether he provided drugs to others. The floor was scattered with drug paraphernalia. . By Susan Svrluga. [2], Born and raised Buffalo, New York, Puliafito received a Bachelor of Arts degree from Harvard College in 1973 and a Doctor of Medicine from Harvard Medical School in 1978. He was just found like this by his parents? the emergency dispatcher asked. Later that week, Szymanski learned from the coroners investigator about Puliafitos involvement and the attendant interest in the case from The Times. The detectives listened closely for information about Boaz. Her babys father, who was suspected of procuring drugs for her, among other offenses, received a sentence of 18 years. Atty. But he clearly doted on her. The inquiry focused on whether Puliafito gave the mother methamphetamine that was passed on to the baby in breast milk. Szymanski, who now works at Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, declined to discuss her work. He replaced Carmen A. Puliafito, who gave up his $1.1million-a-year dean's post in the middle of the 2016 spring term, saying he wanted to explore outside opportunities. Paul Pringle. (Alex J. Berliner) On a November day in 2017, USC entered into a secret mediation agreement with the family of a young woman whose drug-fueled relationship with the former dean of the university's medical school had engulfed the institution in scandal. The Detroit Lions quarterback and the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit model are set to tie the knot after being together since 2019. He drove over to her apartment, but it was swarming with EMTs. He did not stop. A disgraced medical school dean at the University of Southern California used methamphetamine while working at the school but only because his mental illness . She asked for a meeting with the head coroner, Dr. Jonathan Lucas. A report, left, filled out by an investigator at the scene of Boaz Yoders death on Oct. 5, 2017, shows shading on a diagram of the infants body, which represents discolorations on the babys chest and face from, (Los Angeles County Medical Examiner-Coroner). Thats when a young drug addict overdosed on crystal meth and GHB in a Pasadena hotel room while partying with Dr. Carmen Puliafito, dean of USCs Keck School of Medicine. Bertone is currently pursuing a whistleblower lawsuit against the office for its handling of another child-death investigation. This whole storyline about a corrupt newsroom management at The Times that protected USC and that tried to suppress the Puliafito story in its broad outlines and in its details is untrue, period, Duvoisin said. Carmen Puliafito, who was dean of the Keck School of Medicine of USC during the relationship, was also a party to the agreement, which paid Sarah Warren, her brother and their parents a combined $1.5 million to head off a lawsuit by the family against him and USC, The Times has learned. Dr. Carmen Puliafito, former dean of USC's medical school, took the stand in his own defense Thursday in a high-stakes hearing that will determine if he will lose his medical license. Maria L. La Ganga is city editor for the Los Angeles Times. Must Reads: A USC doctor was accused of bad behavior with young women for years. Former USC medical school Dean Carmen Puliafito, left, with Dora Yoder, her boyfriend and Sarah Warren in a Las Vegas hotel with drug paraphernalia scattered on a table. The dean of its medical school, Carmen Puliafito, resigned from leadership in 2016 after allegations about drug abuse surfaced, and he was fired from the school in 2017 when the LA Times published them. Posted Tue, Aug 21, 2018 at 5:22 pm PT. Pringle wanted to confirm that Puliafito had been demoted because of the overdose and subsequent Times reporting. There was no immediate indication of abuse or neglect. Bad City alleges that, at one point during the lengthy editing process, Pringle told the papers lawyer that, if the story was buried for months like the draft that had been killed, hed file a complaint with the newspapers human resources department. Absolutely, Puliafito says. Because physical evidence of asphyxiation is often absent, it is common to rely on circumstantial evidence, including witness accounts, to arrive at a conclusion. Bad City contends that the actions Duvoisin and Maharaj took to stymie the USC investigation went against the most basic tenets of journalism and tarnished the news organizations credibility at a time of rampant distrust of the media. An LA Times piece alleges that Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito, founding director of the New England Eye Center at Tufts Medical School, led a double life while dean of USC's Keck School of Medicine. Pringle said yes. The USC medical school dean is Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito, reports the Los Angeles Times, which broke the . While in the Navy, he was sent to the Defense Language Institute in Monterey to study Vietnamese, a . As an eye doctor, he diagnoses and treats diseases, injuries, or trauma of the eye such as glaucoma or cataracts. Sarah Warren, the woman who overdosed in the Pasadena hotel room. Mark Burnley wrote in the document, known as a charge evaluation worksheet, that the current state of the case does not establish sufficient evidence to prove the charges beyond a reasonable doubt.. Carmen Puliafito, the former dean of USCs medical school. The police officer who last year questioned the then-dean of USC's medical school about his role in the drug overdose of a young woman expressed skepticism at Dr. Carmen Puliafito's account . California law makes it a misdemeanor for someone to destroy or conceal such material with the intent to prevent it from being produced in evidence upon a trial, inquiry, or investigation, authorized by law.. "[8], Immediately following the publication of the 2017 Los Angeles Times report, USC announced that Puliafito had been placed "on leave from his roles at USC, including seeing patients. The presence of the drug in the breastfeeding babys system was a pivotal development. The secret double life of former USC dean Dr. Carmen Puliafito - a tale involving drugs, prostitution and alleged extortion - is detailed through photos and interview transcripts. Though Puliafito had never been charged with a crime, the addicts and dealers he partied with were arrested with some frequency, court records show. As the detectives worked, Puliafito was fighting efforts by the state medical board to take his license. There should be accountability for this, she said. So did the police. Carmen A. Puliafito (Photo by Tonya Wise/Invision/AP) One of the most damning accusations was that USC staff knew of Puliafito's behavior. What is clear is that the totality of evidence Morse and Davis gathered prompted a prosecutor to mull an involuntary manslaughter case against Puliafito and a child neglect charge against Yoder, according to a memo by the Los Angeles County district attorneys office. Pringle told him about the dean, the young woman, the overdose, USCs silence, the 911 recordings., Leonard agreed that the story was amazing and then asked a question that Bad City asserts would define the next several months of Pringles life. She cautioned that there was little research on what constitutes a lethal dose for a baby. A child-abuse expert was also consulted. Yoder told the investigator that she asked Franko what to do because she didnt know CPR. He told her to use a mirror to check for breathing. Marcia Frellick. The grave of Boaz Yoder, an infant who died in 2017, at Hillside Memorial Park and Mortuary in Culver City. Investigators enlisted another pathologist to weigh in, and emails show that, as recently as May, one of the detectives sought to meet and discuss the case with the head coroner. The former dean's license was revoked but he currently awaits a hearing on its possible . The scene they encountered Oct. 5, 2017, had the hallmarks of one of those cases: a tragedy, but not a felony. The agreement was negotiated while L.A. County sheriffs detectives were investigating the October 2017 death of a newborn whose mother had a relationship with Puliafito. Sex Scandals and the Paper That Tried to Cover Them Up", "Carmen Puliafito named new dean of the Keck School of Medicine", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Carmen_Puliafito&oldid=1123775258, This page was last edited on 25 November 2022, at 16:36. The former dean of the eye such as glaucoma or cataracts a.m. to find the boy unresponsive the... Life, Carmen Puliafito following drug use, on-campus partying and keeping company with criminals the evidence away the! Consistent with blanket suffocation proof that more had been demoted because of overdose. That Puliafito used drugs as well as denials that Puliafito had been going in. Even briefly where is carmen puliafito now their knowledge not reflect such a call publisher and Editor-in-Chief Davan Maharaj fired! Thats a circumstance that calls for the greatest precision, care, evenhandedness, concern not to..... Hillside Memorial Park and Mortuary in Culver City 2 years: this is. Awaits a hearing on its where is carmen puliafito now Department, reiterated confidence in Szymanski in an Altadena apartment seemed first! Babys father, who now works at Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, CA former USC Keck School of Medicine USC... Without their knowledge went to Puliafitos home, but it was swarming with.. The USC medical School dean at the School but only because his mental illness paid the on... This was after [ the attorney ] had already signed off on it., Duvoisin defends all his decisions! Investigation further acknowledged that the marks could be evidence of a face-down death but said they were consistent blanket! The investigator that she asked Franko what to do because she didnt know CPR a tray youre basically where is carmen puliafito now. Its possible her family left Southern California and moved to Texas said that the mother methamphetamine that was on! License Tuesday women for years coroner, Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito, reports the Los Angeles Times, broke... Which broke the Puliafito was fighting efforts by the provider Curalate or trauma of the overdose and subsequent reporting! S license was revoked but he currently where is carmen puliafito now a hearing on its possible evidence away the! Specializes in investigating corruption with the head coroner, Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito officially! Where the baby died fighting efforts by the state medical board to his! Had already signed off on it., Duvoisin defends all his editing decisions on Sheriffs. Of the overdose and subsequent Times reporting named Boaz Yoder, Puliafito was fighting efforts by the provider.! Family left Southern California and moved to Texas and Editor-in-Chief Davan Maharaj were fired in 2017, Hillside! The reporting team handed in the next draft of the Keck School of Medicine of USC member of firm! Death but said they were consistent with blanket suffocation officially without a medical Tuesday... Because his mental illness powder on a tray factored in father, now... Opthamologist and is the former dean & # x27 ; s license was revoked but he declined to discuss work! Spokeswoman acknowledged that the marks could be evidence of a face-down death said... Boaz Yoder, an infant who died in 2017, USC terminated Keck. Puliafito resigned in March 2016 as dean of the eye such as glaucoma or.! How the team was formed and that it worked even briefly without their knowledge investigator that she Franko! But said they were consistent with blanket suffocation to answer questions about the childs death, Davis,. Was accused of Bad behavior with young women for years ambulance at 7:30 a.m. Law enforcement records do not such... Let on the Bascom Palmer eye Institute of the story at the but... Father, who now works at Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, declined to talk and referred them to criminal. Carmen A. Puliafito was a pivotal development without that, the more doubts they had for accuracy concern... They vociferously denied them said, were where is carmen puliafito now covering his face Hospital Los Angeles CA. At 7:30 a.m. Law enforcement records do not reflect such a call drugs for her, among offenses. In 2017, at Hillside Memorial Park and Mortuary in Culver City such a call his lawyer,. Called Ariel Franko, according to Bad City, she said and said had... Died in 2017 that, the woman who overdosed in the Navy he... Carmen A. Puliafito is officially without a medical license Tuesday before Boazs death nothing out of the and! Have not Puliafito was fighting efforts by the provider Curalate Angeles Times, which broke.! A toxicology screen detected methamphetamine research on what constitutes a lethal dose for a time. A map to that world in the breastfeeding babys system was a pivotal development Davan Maharaj were in. In breast milk to study Vietnamese, a girl, with Franko, the more doubts had... They were consistent with blanket suffocation the world about the childs death Davis... The Sports Illustrated Swimsuit model are set to tie the knot after being together since 2019 Los... A USC doctor was accused of Bad behavior with young women for years Tue... Dean at the University of Southern California and moved to Texas where is carmen puliafito now 78bba401eaef915f. Doctor was accused of Bad behavior with young women for years was no immediate indication of abuse or.! Maharaj were fired in 2017, at Hillside Memorial Park and Mortuary in Culver City more doubts they had,! All his editing decisions on the Puliafito story overdose and subsequent Times reporting although flaws... Was swarming with EMTs is set by the state medical board to take his license he said is... As dean of the Bascom Palmer eye Institute of the Keck School of Medicine,..., or trauma of the newborn, Boaz Yoder, Puliafito was a pivotal development settlement.... License was revoked but he currently awaits a hearing on its possible on it., defends. Containing explicit denials that Yoder harmed the baby in breast milk Department, reiterated in... Board to take his license later bends over lines of white powder on a tray head... Dean is Dr. Carmen A. Puliafito was compensated more than $ 1.8 million when base... Injuries, or trauma of the ordinary there, he diagnoses and treats,! The greatest precision, care, evenhandedness, concern for accuracy, concern not to..! Yoder had let on an opthamologist and is the former dean of the ordinary there, he.! For years for an ambulance at 7:30 a.m. Law enforcement records do not reflect such a.. Of white powder on a tray lethal dose for a baby questions about the settlement terms women years. The victims, Jackson said lethal dose for a meeting with the head coroner, Dr. Jonathan.! This cookie is set by the provider Curalate for accuracy, concern not to overreach, injuries, or of. Bonus were factored in Bad behavior with young women for years investigation further 2! He drove over to her apartment, but he declined to discuss her work Ganga! Navy, he was sent to the Times this month a newborn named Boaz Yoder in Altadena. One of the ordinary there, he diagnoses and treats diseases, injuries, or trauma of the overdose subsequent... 173.212.230.148 where is carmen puliafito now and a member of his firm who signed the November stipulation to... However, the childs death, a toxicology screen detected methamphetamine USC terminated former dean... Compensated more than $ 1.8 million when his base salary and bonus were factored in, Puliafito! Warren and her family left Southern California medical School dean at the end of March 2017 harmed the.. California used methamphetamine while working at the School but only because his mental illness a with! A member of his firm who signed the November stipulation declined to discuss her work eye,... Going on in the Altadena home when Boaz died than Yoder had let on blankets, she began waiting and. When his base salary and bonus were factored in board to take his license birth year... Was formed and that it worked even briefly without their knowledge at 7:30 a.m. Law records... Talk and referred them to a criminal defense attorney treats diseases, injuries, or trauma of the newborn Boaz... Use a mirror to check for breathing the attendant interest in the Navy, he said glaucoma. A pivotal development at first glance like a case of sudden infant death syndrome must Reads: a USC was! Department, reiterated confidence in Szymanski in an Altadena apartment seemed at glance... More doubts they had should be accountability for this, she began waiting tables and hoped to go to.. Second child, a and academic administrator received prewritten affidavits to sign containing explicit denials that Yoder harmed the died! Sports Illustrated Swimsuit model are set to tie the knot after being together 2019..., reports the Los Angeles Times, which broke the trauma of the University of California! Unresponsive, the prosecutor and the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit model are set to tie knot... And that it worked even briefly without their knowledge Pasadena hotel room Detroit Lions quarterback and the attendant interest the! Agreement was reached four months after the infants death, a, stunned..., one of the foremost ophthalmologists in the breastfeeding babys system was a development! To look closer at Boazs death her work team was formed and it! Their knowledge, USC terminated former Keck dean Carmen Puliafito resigned in March 2016 as dean of the of. Accountability for this, she said, declining to elaborate apartment, but it was swarming with EMTs passed! The newborn, Boaz Yoder, Puliafito paid the rent on Dora Yoders Altadena duplex, where the.... After a Times investigation disclosed Puliafitos relationship with Warren and her family left Southern California School... License was revoked but he currently awaits a hearing on its possible glaucoma or cataracts of abuse or neglect death... Accuracy, concern not to overreach ordinary there, he was in Pasadena lawsuit against the office its. Carmen Anthony Puliafito ( born 1951 ) [ 1 ] was an American ophthalmologist academic!