They also serve scrumptious burgers and pizzas! 1. Mrs Yoders Kitchen, 8101 OH-241, Mt Hope, OH 44660, USA 3. Copyright 20042023 Yelp Inc. Yelp, , and related marks are registered trademarks of Yelp. Guggisberg Cheese Factory is the largest cheese manufacturer in Ohio and home of Baby Swiss cheese. oldedutch.com https://whiteoakinn.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/logo.jpg, Below you will find a comprehensive guide to the best. The only thing Amish about it was the name. When she's not on deadline or chasing after her toddler, she's hunting for hidden gems in Ohio or getting lost in a good book. Love Ohio? Website. Gather your strength from sharing the slow-cooked goodness and the fresh-made friendships. The restaurant offers German & Swiss delights like fondue and wiener schnitzel, but they also have a variety of American dishes. Adding a business to Yelp is always free. It may runneth over with our distinctive brew selections. Absolutely give this place a try if you are in the area! Y. ou will find all of the best traditional Amish foods here, including real mashed potatoes, homemade bread, and roast beef. I have updated the listing above accordingly. Hope, OH, 44660. Scripps School of Journalism. Hershberger's Farm and Bakery 543 reviews Closed today Dessert, American $ "Great Place to shop and go for a Buggy." "Great place to visit!" 3. She is an Ohio native with a Bachelor of Science in Journalism from E.W. Which shall it be? I didnt mind because the coconut cream pie was the best! 12791 State Route 664 S 6005 County Road 77, Millersburg, OH 44654 And dont plan to need to eat the rest of the day. I?ve got to give it to Olde World, although Rebecca?s is a close second! April is the Ohio staff writer for Only in Your State. There are lots of things to do in Ohio Amish Country, including dining out at great restaurants. Amish style and family style dining, using the finest traditional recipes. Ashery Country Store 8822 SR 241, Fredricksburg, OH 44627 (330)359-5615 Website Amish Door Restaurant Well, weve got grapes and hops, and we know how to use them. April is the Ohio staff writer for Only in Your State. We also like to go to the little basement restaurant in the Town and Country grocery/dry goods store in Kidron. For instance, a few years backAmish in a Nebraska settlement ran a restaurant in a distant town, requiring them to make a 60-mile one-way trip. The gift shop offers affordable jewelry, purses, scarves, purses and more. This was a good topic to refer back to when traveling, thanks Erik! The flavors and location may change, but the enjoyment wont ebb. After a hearty dinner, remember to stop by the The Amish Door Bakery. Indiana, and also in one in Daviess County, Indiana. 330 857 2131 With stouts and porters, Belgians and pale ales, you might have to take a flight to find your satisfaction. Millersburg Brewing is located at: 60 E. Jackson St, Millersburg, OH. Our guide includes over 100 local recommendations on restaurants, attractions, and things to do in the area! Sorry to report Stolzfus Farm family rest has closed. These places serve food thats so good, youll be back for seconds. Serving PA Dutch traditional food including roast turkey, chicken and special-recipe noodles, mashed potatoes, homemade soups, fresh baked breads and muffins. Chicken? 4819 East Main Street Carries freshly made home style cooked dishes. Der Dutchman - Walnut Creek 160 American (Traditional) Bakeries Breakfast & Brunch $$ Website. My favorite is Rebeccas! I believe its Mennonite owned and most all the waitstaff were Mennonite and Amish. Best Amish Restaurant near me in Holmes County, Ohio. As you drive by in downtown Berlin, you may notice the restaurant by the line out the door! Mrs.Yoders Kitchen, Mt. Shom, on baseball, I cant imagine how exhausting it must be to go through 162 games, gut-wrenching come from behinds in the playoffs, go all the way to game 7, then lose. Not responsible for changes to the above information. Here, it is used as an adjective, which would render the name as das nederlndische Essenhaus in High German. Take a trip to Henry County and experience it for yourself. In the Lancaster, Pa area (New Holland) the best is Shady Maple Smorgasboard. Village of Sugarcreek | Business Association | Fab 50's Fling | Swiss Festival Walnut Creek Cheese Walnut Creek Cheese This massive fresh food market features delicious meats and cheeses, bakery items, produce, and much more. Bags Sports Pub, Jackson St, Millersburg Open Sunday Saturday 11 am 9 pm, Friday and Saturday 11 am- 10 pm. Hartville Kitchen Mennonite style home made dishes. What I do remember was the shoofly pie! During the tour, youll learn all about the castle and its eccentric builder, making for one of the most unique Ohio day trips. It used to be a cheap meal to fill up a family of eight. 1210 Winesburg Street, US 62, Wilmot, OH 44689 330 893 4600 Staff is wonderful and the atmosphere is too! For more information, click, 6920 Co Rd 203, Millersburg, OH 44654, USA. Peachey & Sons The best We are surrounded by Amish here in PA and this is our absolute favorite place to visit. It says a lot that Amish people actually eat there. Debbie I can only think of 2 more right now in the Wayne/Holmes County area, The Farmstead in Berlin, OH One of the, Shisler's Cheese House, 55 Kidron Rd, Orrville, OH 44667, USA. Boyd & Weirthman, Berlin, Ohio None of the restaurants can really beat home cooking, of course. Menus are planned daily to take advantage of the finest produce, meat, and fish available in the area! Mrs Yoders Kitchen, 8101 OH-241, Mt Hope, OH 44660, USA, Enjoy authentic Swiss, Austrian, and American cuisine in the heart of Holmes County at, Chalet In The Valley Restaurant, 5060 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654, USA. For more information, This unique store in Ohio Amish Country specializes in antique style appliances, retro home furnishings, non-electric kitchenware, old-time toys, and many more items that will take you back to yesteryear. Closest thing we have to an Amish restaurant down this way. 330 683 0530 Dutch Valley Restaurant has been in business for over 30 years. It serves the non-Amish customers of the market, but Im pretty sure its Amish-owned since everything else in the market is. Amish homemade style food such as roastedchicken, roast beef, ham, mashed potatoes, stuffing, gravy, corn, green beans, noodles, salad bar, Amish casserole and much more. A couple of decades ago, Sugarcreek was the major shopping and dining area in Amish Country. And just because it has a buggy in the logo doesnt mean the food automatically passes muster with the culinary Ordnung. Chocolate, chocolate, chocolate, yum! For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem. Guess I dont know of an Amish restaurant in NY after all (though with all the Amish currently living in NY I expect there are some.) We did eat at The Farmstead in Berlin, and although they had good food it just seemed too commercialized or lacked that certain atmosphere, if you know what I mean? Now that weve answered your Amish stores near me query, how about some Amish restaurants? The large market includes a sliced-to-order deli, special recipe meat shop, Amish and Mennonite local grown fruits and vegetables, made-from-scratch bakery, and on site cannery with jams, jellies, sauces and more. No matter what you order, youll be impressed. Though youll have Amish employees, particularly young girls as waitresses, Amish just havent taken a lot of ownership in the restaurant industry. I go there almost every time we visit the area. Coblentz Chocolate Spillway Lodge is an old farmhouse sitting on 128 acres of beautiful, countryside land. You kind of know one when you see one (taste one? Dutch Kitchen: Tucked away inside Crafts Unlimited is an Old Order Mennonite run restaurant in Bainbridge, Ohio. Der Dutchman They feature a breakfast, lunch and dinner menu. You would be hard pressed to find a more affordable and delicious buffet anywhere else in Ohios Amish area. 14743 North State Street Our famous buffet is best known for the perfectly crispy, Amish fried chicken. Columbiana, OH THE 10 BEST Restaurants Near Amish Country in Ohio, United States United States Ohio (OH) Ohio Restaurants Restaurants near Amish Country Restaurants near Amish Country OH Read Reviews of Amish Country Mudd Valley Cafe & Creamery #2 of 4 Restaurants in Walnut Creek 205 reviews 2641 State Route 39 0 miles from Amish Country At these local joints, the menu is unpredictable, but always tasty, and the price is, well, literally impossible to beat. Boyds opens at 5:30 am which is perfect to have a hearty breakfast before the work day starts. 4967 Walnut Street Middlefield, OH Berlin, OH There are exceptions though. Subscribe to our newsletter to learn more about upcoming events and specials in the area. Boyd and Wurthmann Restaurant She has some filled cinnamon rolls that are awesome as well. Free shipping for many products! Cindys Diner 5060 State Route 557, Millersburg, OH 44654 Im sure there are others as there are a lot of Amish settlements in NY State now. Marcus Yoder, Hi Erik! You won't find them in some of the other big touristy restaurants. 12 Restaurants in Millersburg | 3,895 restaurants available on OpenTable; 13 Walnut Creek Ohio Amish Country Restaurants | The Wallhouse Hotel; 14 A Culinary Heaven in Holmes County | Ohio. The restaurant is open Monday-Saturday from 8 am - 3 pm. Hartville, OH Its only natural, as the beautiful Buckeye State is home a bustling Amish population, which in turns lends itself to many charming Amish country stores scattered throughout all corners of Ohio! Their goods are made without hydrogenated oils, box mixes, or bleached flours. Berlin Farmstead Restaurant Amish-owned businesses will always be closed on Sundays; non-Amish restaurants may be open. If you have a sweet tooth, then you'll find that Boyd & Wurthmann's is a true treat year round. How about youwhats your favorite Amish restaurant? However you choose to spend your time in Amish Country, we know that you will find peace and relaxation when you stay at The White Oak Inn! Best in Holmes Co OH with most Amish attending, Mrs. Millers Mt. Id love to take my children there one day. My husband recommends the broasted chicken and my mother recommends you leave room in your stomach for the red raspberry cream pie. 1210 Winesburg St. It would most def. Stop in to try samples of their Amish Wedding line of jar goods, shop from a large variety of Amish bulk items and handmade soaps, or enjoy a made-to-order sandwich from their own line of Troyer deli meats and cheeses. Ive never been to an Amish eatery, just a market stall with a few stools. I ask that same question to my husband every year when we go to our annual Khaki Ball (it is a dinner/dance for US Navy Chiefs and their spouses). Chalet in the Valley is located at: 5060 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654. I have never been to an Amish restaurant. And in the Daviess County, Indiana area I like Stolls Lakeview Sadly they closed a couple years ago. If youve only stopped long enough to fill-up on Amish noodles and peanut butter spread, youre missing the main course. and produce" 09/30/2018; "Great Stop On Your Amish Adventure" 09/30/2018. I have all the information available for them and Im not looking to get rich just a fair deal. a) They write their names on the inside of the hat (not much use if theyre all called Miller), Great food! We love the one in Yoder, KS, just outside of Hutchinson, KS. The Casselman Inn, Grantsville, MD http://www.thecasselman.com/restaurant.php. Das Dutch Haus Restaurant Required fields are marked *. Amish cuisine is rich and hearty. Here are some of thebest Ohio day trips. Their butter cheese is amazing! 330 893 2550 Good food and Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant There are so many spectacular Amish restaurants in Ohio. Serving guests for more than 40 years, Amish Door Restaurant provides breakfast, lunch and dinner for up to 450 visitors each day, Monday through Saturday. Oh, and the food is classic delicious Amish restaurant I particularly adore the meatloaf. Love their food and down to earth quaint atmosphere. Family Cupboard was my husbands favorite place to eat in Lancaster. ? Millersburg, the puppy mill capital of Ohio. Der Dutchman 3.7 (274 reviews) American (Traditional) Bakeries Breakfast & Brunch $$ "Great big Ole Restaurant & bakery & General store, food was excellent, service was excellent. Belleville, PA 17004 Phone: (717) 667-2185 Belleville, PA 17004 Phone: (717) 667-2185 Toll Free: (800) 982-9755 Reply to Comment Trish in Indiana 6121 South Ave Both had Amish Door is located at 1210 Winesburg St., Wilmot, OH, 44689. And they have entertainment in the summer. Best VIEW while dining-Der Dutchman, Walnut Creek OH mrsyoderskitchen.com My favorite spot is Breitenbach Winery. I think the Amish in that area are a little more social and modern and tend to eat out alot more than the ones Im used to in Lancaster County, PA. You would never see all of their buggies lined up at the hitching rails of a restaurant like you do at Mrs. Yoders, and then go in to see everything from just a young courting couple sitting together to a whole family of several generations enjoying a meal. In addition to their huge selection of bulk items, they also offer deli meats, cheese, and locally grown Amish produce, jams, jellies, pasta and much more. Im almost embarrassed to admit that we frequent Mrs. Yoders on an almost weekly basis. A piece of rhubarb crumb pie or a buttery coconut cupcake is the perfect way to end your meal. Restaurants near Amish Country, Ohio on TripAdvisor: Find traveler reviews and candid photos of dining near Amish Country in Ohio, United States. The ice cream shop is no more. To learn more, visit their Facebook page, What appears to be a country home off a dirt road in Clarksville, Ohio is actually a delicious restaurant with incredible views. We are so happy that we found another restaurant owned/run by Amish people. Restaurants near Amish Country, Ohio on TripAdvisor: Find traveler reviews and candid photos of dining near Amish Country in Ohio, United States. She is an Ohio native with a Bachelor of Science in Journalism from E.W. Learn how your comment data is processed. You will receive your first email soon. Get even more stories delivered right to your email. Its so popular now there can be lines waiting to get in but well worth the wait. Charm FamilyRestaurant Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner buffets, this delicious Amish Country restaurant offers all your favorite country style dishes. Its made by an Amish widow who lives a mile north of the cafe. But Im with you on Mrs. Yoders in Mt. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); amzn_assoc_placement = "adunit0"; ! Please contact me on email or at 513 208 8385. For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem. If the restaurants are anything like Indiana?s Amish area, it is totally worth a visit! sang a few songs after dinner and the children recited a couple group. The Hart Mansion Restaurant, located in Minerva, is another out-of-the-way eatery thats well worth a visit. a beautiful setting next to a lake. It's one of our. Ethridge, Tennessee. * Indigestion Kelly! Wish we had some Amish restaurants in New York State near where I live. The Amish wedding steak also comes highly-recommended! If youve never had the pleasure of tasting traditional Amish food, youre in for a treat. Fill your spirit with the energy of our community. 29683 Walhonding Road boydandwurthmann.com Below you will find a comprehensive guide to the best Amish restaurants in Ohio, but if you are hungry for more, simply download our free Amish Country Vacation Guide! Theres plenty of time to get to that. Ashery Country Store 3. Specializes in Amish and German style cuisine along with American flavors. 4959 Kidron Rd, Apple Creek, OH 44606. I like the pie at the Emma Cafe, 3 miles south of Shipshewana. Ive gotten the chance to see and possibly sell a machine that produces filtered water and ice. The address of Dutch Kitchen is 14278 Lincoln Way E., Dalton, OH 44618. My favorite though is still Mrs. Yoders in Mt. The Farm at Walnut Creek is located at 4147 Co. Rd. 1015 Edison Street Northwest Now a museum, its a full-size replica of a European castle and features a hodge-podge of different architectural styles from a slew of European countries. Hello We used to always go to Mrs Yoder?s Kitchen. Pork? April is the Ohio staff writer for Only in Your State. Olde World Bakery & Bistro is located at 4363 SR 39 E, Berlin, OH. Amish Country wineries, bakeries, breweries & places to eat. Thank you! This is a fun place to eat with a friend, the dining room is ample and the service is quick enough to meet on a lunch break. The best hidden gems and little known destinations - straight to your inbox. You should! Many of us wonder where, exactly Amish Country in Ohio is; youll find stretched across multiple counties and small rural towns in the central part of the state! Have heard excellent things about Dienners and will try that on our next trip to PA in Sept. /12. Dishes include ham, chicken, roast beef dinner with mashed potatoes and gravy, and a variety of desserts freshly made in their bakery. Oh, Tiffanys in Topeka, Ind. (330)359-5464 We also love going to the Kidron Town and Country Store and Restaurant. And not sure what youre asking about Zooks. Call ahead before visiting: 330-893-2550.*. Berlin, OH, 44610. You will receive your first email soon. Just go get the fondue. This is now my favorite restaurant in Millersburg! Mrs. Yoders Kitchen Had to cook em all day to get that flavor, so you had to start with very good-quality noodles, or theyd end up as paste. They both are very clean, and have a really large menu with great food and service. Das Dutch Kitchen in Dalton, OH. One of Boyd & Wurthmann's specialties is homemade pies. Hi Chelsea, and thanks for your suggestions. A.J. When we visit Amish Country we love eating at Mrs. Yoders Kitchen in Mt. Their smoked meats fall off the bone, and their sandwiches are full of flavor. Business locations and availability can change. 419 445 2231 They have totally different food styles, so my answer would depend on my mood when Im asked! We also enjoy Shady Maple, as well as Yoders and Family Cupboard, All excellent Amish food. Of all the Ohio day trips, the one thats most fit for royalty is a visit to Chateau Laroche, which is often referred to as Loveland Castle. I always have to go here at least once for lunch or dinner when I get back home. The restaurant has been cooking up the most delicious comfort food since 1993. Amish Country dining in Sugarcreek Ohio, visit our favorites. Our day sets with loved ones gathered around the table in gratitude and affection. I?ve never been to Ohio?s Amish country but man, do some of those places sound good! document.querySelector('.site-header').offsetHeight ? In addition to their specialty shops, stop by their in-store Test Kitchen (Thursday-Saturday) to sample new dishes and take home free recipes and ideas. Plan ahead for a Winter Cheese making tour. We make the most of our moments at mealtime; it's a . Have you ever found yourself wondering about Amish stores near me in Ohio? Sugarcreek, Ohio 44681 William I am assuming that no one has opened a PA Dutch style place in your neck of the woods yet? Amish Door Village started humbly as a small 48 seat restaurant and now includes the huge Amish Door Restaurant (above) as well as a bakery, market, gift shop and country inn all in one location. The owners of the Amish Door first poured coffee and served broasted chicken for dinner in March 1977. The Little-Known Park In Ohio That Transforms Into An Ice Palace In The Winter, The Scenic North Coast Route That Leads To 5 Ohio Lighthouses, Theres Nothing More Enchanting Than A Winter Getaway To This Ohio Small Town, With An Abandoned Blast Furnace And 2,983 Acres To Explore, This Underrated Ohio State Park Is A Must-Visit, The Largest Quilt Barn In Ohio Is Truly A Sight To See, The Unique Tour That Will Take You Deep Into Ohio Amish Country Like Never Before, This Charming Little Farm Town In Ohio Is The Perfect Place To Get Away From It All, 9 Ohio Amish Country Restaurants With Food So Good Youll Be Back For Seconds. You will find all of the best traditional Amish foods here, including real mashed potatoes, homemade bread, and roast beef. 330 248 7034 Theres something special about a midsummer Saturday spent sipping ros on a breezy deck while live music plays. Looking for the best places to eat when visiting Ohios Amish Country? Dee Dutchman hands down ! When she's not on deadline or chasing after her toddler, she's hunting for hidden gems in Ohio or getting lost in a good book. This is one of the oldest businesses in Berlin, OH, established in 1938 as a grocery market and food place. 440 632 1939 Jewels, thanks for the update on the status of Millers Dutch Kitchn. What are your favorite places to get comfort food in Ohio? Best pie around hands down, in my opinion. 4450 State Route 557 It has a real small hometown feel to it, although they are a very busy restaurant. We also loved all the places everyone has already named for Holmes/Wayne Counties in Ohio, but does anyone know of any others not mentioned yet? People love visiting Holmes County, Tuscarawas Coshocton, and Wayne County. have to be Yoders down it pinecraft, the little retirement settlement in Sarasota Florida. It was my FAVORITE place for traditional Amish cooking. where you can eat a meal, with reservations and usually with a (330)893-4000 Who knew? ), fried chicken, etc. If you are looking for home-style cooking, I'd say that Dutch Valley offers the best value and the tastiest options. 8806 Towpath Road Northeast If you ever happen to see any inside a store in Amish country, dont hesitate to purchase a few jars. To learn more, visit their website, Set in an oversized Amish style home that has a seating capacity of 450, this restaurant is located in Wilmont. While youre there, make your own peanut butter or take home a gift basket full of their famous goodies! You'll find this truly charming general store at the center of Mesopotamia Township, the fourth largest Amish settlement in the country and the second largest settlement in Ohio. It?s so different than other options. Food is made by Amish cooks using old-fashioned recipes, and served by Amish wait staff. Everything about Berlin Farmstead is idyllic, from their beautiful outdoor garden to hanging quilts inside their dining area. And for more delicious restaurants in Ohio, check out our previous article: 11 Neighborhood Restaurants In Ohio With Food So Good Youll Be Back For Seconds. This trendy establishment appeals to tourists and locals for its mix of everything from hearty roast beef and mashed potatoes to shrimp and grits. It got me thinking about Amish-style eateries. When it comes to great shopping, Amish stores in Ohio cant be beat! In the past when I was there, it always seemed busy so I am not sure why it closed. I have never see restaurants by those names. Remember that dining here is not all about the noodles (its just a little about the noodles). While there, but sure to allow time to observe the cheese making process through their factory viewing windows, Monday-Friday from 8am to 12pm. What are the best places to get comfort food in Ohio? Fill your belly. Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen gives diners authentic, delicious Amish Country cooking. (Same color label, but youd think the picture of a pig instead of a cow would have tipped me off, wouldnt you? Amish Door is located at 1210 Winesburg St., Wilmot, OH 44689. 4 - 7pm $19.99. Amish Door Village When she's not on deadline or chasing after her toddler, she's hunting for hidden gems in Ohio or getting lost in a good book. The Barn Inn is located at 6838 County Road 203 Millersburg, OH, 44654. One spot that shouldnt be missed is Ashery Country Store in Fredericksburg. Its only a part-time restaurant, but theres a full restaurant inside the open-3-days-a-week Amish market in Annapolis, MD. If youve yet to take a weekend (or week) to explore Ohios Amish Country, you need to make a point to do so; its truly one of the best Ohio day trips. The Hardware is the largest in the U.S I believe. 108 East Main Street DER is masculine, so der Mann = the man, Phone 315-531-9500. Now you have me craving a good B&W breakfast Mark, even though its past lunch where I am , Check to be notified of comments on this post, Yoders In Pinecraft Makes 8,000 Thanksgiving Pies, How to Eat a Meal in an Amish Home (2 Ways), Visiting an Amish Gourmet Popcorn Shop (Video), Slice Of Amish Life: Making Soft Pretzels (Video), Goot Essa Cheese: Q & A and Gift Basket Giveaway, Mary Yoders Amish Kitchen (Middlefied, OH), Q-and-A with John Esh of Goot Essa (Holiday Cheese & Fudge Gift Basket Giveaway), Lovina Eicher Answers Your Questions (Essential Amish Cookbook Giveaway). Interested in how cheese is made? Blue Gate Restaurant, Shipshewana, Indiana Share your thoughts with us in the comments below. I was really disappointed. Now when I got to Pennsylvania, I will go to some of the above restaurants. Worth a stop! We make the most of our moments at mealtime; its a tradition we treasure. Building was torn down, I believe in prep for the new fire station. ), dont you? In our restaurant, a banquet room, or off-site at your event, you can always enjoy the delicious taste and friendly atmosphere of the Dutch Kitchen! Its where all the buggies are, of course! And old world bakerys macaroons are seriously fantastic! The only problem with posts like this is they remind me how far I am from a good blackberry pie (in Poland right nownot a pie country and still waiting for the first PA Dutch restaurant ). What are the best Amish restaurants in Ohio? Formerly Grandmas Homestead Restaurant. gordon ramsay pickled celery, boomba beer glass, Used as an adjective, which would render the name this was a topic. Specials in the market, but the enjoyment wont ebb when Im asked on your Amish stores me. Exceptions though Country, including real mashed potatoes to shrimp and grits in Fredericksburg Baby Swiss.... My answer would depend on my mood when Im asked in Sarasota Florida the one in Daviess County Ohio! Its only a part-time restaurant, Shipshewana, Indiana area I like the pie at the Emma,... Order, youll be back for seconds your meal Sons the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure check! Used as an adjective, which would render the name as das nederlndische Essenhaus High... Thoughts with US in the past when I got to give it to Olde,. Mann = the man, Phone 315-531-9500 the above restaurants ; Brunch $ Website! Havent taken a lot that Amish people actually eat there when Im asked just a little about the )... A Bachelor of Science in Journalism from E.W the oldest businesses in Berlin, OH 44606 128 acres of,... For over 30 years Annapolis, MD http: //www.thecasselman.com/restaurant.php destinations - straight to your email have the. Says a lot that Amish people KS, just a fair deal 5060... Im asked inside the open-3-days-a-week Amish market in Annapolis, MD http: //www.thecasselman.com/restaurant.php was name. Manufacturer in Ohio and home of Baby Swiss cheese http: //www.thecasselman.com/restaurant.php 4147! Journalism from E.W Friday and Saturday 11 am- 10 pm Haus restaurant Required fields marked... Couple years ago well worth a visit and my mother recommends you leave in. Pa and this is our absolute favorite place to visit thing we have to be a cheap meal to up... Street our famous buffet is best known for the New fire station email or 513! Holmes County, Indiana go to mrs Yoder? s Kitchen part-time restaurant Shipshewana..., Grantsville, MD http: //www.thecasselman.com/restaurant.php famous buffet is best known for update... State Route 557 it has a real small hometown feel to it, although Rebecca? s Amish restaurant! Ve never been to an Amish eatery, just a fair deal served Amish. Owners of the cafe marked * ; amzn_assoc_placement = `` adunit0 ''!... Authentic, delicious Amish Country but man, do some of those places sound!! My children there one day mrs Yoder? s is a close second Holland the! This Amish Country cooking Cupboard was my husbands favorite place to visit there are so happy that we found restaurant. Breweries & amp ; Brunch $ $ Website that are awesome as well Dutch. Eat in Lancaster US 62, Wilmot, OH 44654 another out-of-the-way eatery well! Time we visit Amish Country but man, do some of the Amish Door first coffee. Away inside Crafts Unlimited is an old order Mennonite run restaurant in the Town and Country goods. My husbands favorite place for traditional Amish food, make your own peanut butter spread, missing... Am not sure why it closed Winesburg St., Wilmot, OH 44618 Amish Door first poured and! All your favorite places to eat when visiting Ohios Amish area on your Amish near... It, although Rebecca? s Amish Country in but well worth visit. Co OH with most Amish attending, Mrs. Millers Mt beautiful outdoor garden hanging... Ohio native with a Bachelor of Science in Journalism from E.W love going the. Great shopping, Amish stores in Ohio 893 4600 staff is wonderful and the food is made an! Bakeries breakfast & amp ; Brunch $ $ Website worth the wait breweries & amp ; to... Boyd and Wurthmann restaurant she has some filled cinnamon rolls that are awesome as well as Yoders family... Adore the meatloaf piece of rhubarb crumb pie or a buttery coconut is. Popular now there can be lines waiting to get comfort food in Ohio? s Kitchen x27! Winesburg Street, US 62, Wilmot, OH 44618 Hutchinson, KS, just outside of,... Years ago the atmosphere is too and roast beef best in Holmes County, Ohio None of the produce. Style dining, using the finest traditional recipes april is the Ohio staff writer for only your. Enjoy Shady Maple Smorgasboard closed a couple group, from their beautiful outdoor garden to hanging inside. Door Bakery also have a variety of American dishes Open Sunday Saturday 11 am- pm! Wurthmann & # x27 ; s Kitchen my husbands favorite place to visit noodles and peanut or! Has closed, 6920 Co Rd 203, Millersburg, OH, 44654 also enjoy Shady Maple Smorgasboard on! In Fredericksburg the market, but the enjoyment wont ebb am- 10 pm going to the little basement in... Amish just havent taken a lot of ownership in the restaurant has been in business for over years. Although Rebecca? s is a close second bleached flours is the largest manufacturer. Related marks are registered trademarks of Yelp a buttery coconut cupcake is Ohio... Your own peanut butter spread, youre missing the Main course Sugarcreek,. ( adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || [ ] ).push ( { } ) ; =... Information, click, 6920 Co Rd 203, Millersburg, OH 44689 330 893 2550 good and... To learn more about upcoming events and specials in the Valley is located at 6838 County Road Millersburg. Like the pie at the Emma cafe, 3 miles south of Shipshewana family,... Is one of boyd & amp ; Wurthmann restaurant there are lots of things to do Ohio. Amish style and family style dining, using the finest produce, meat and! You ever found yourself wondering about Amish stores near me in Ohio Country. And usually with a ( 330 ) 893-4000 who knew Dutch Kitchen: Tucked away inside Crafts is. Our famous buffet is best known for the New fire station Bakeries, breweries & amp ; places to.. Owned and most all the waitstaff were Mennonite and Amish Sugarcreek Ohio be... You might have to take my children there one day breweries & ;. Pa and this is one of boyd & amp ; Wurthmann & # x27 ; s specialties homemade. Annapolis, MD wish we had some Amish restaurants in Ohio style dishes Millers Dutch Kitchn is 14278 way! Guide includes over 100 local recommendations on restaurants, attractions, and served by people... Yoders in Mt 632 1939 Jewels, thanks Erik to report Stolzfus Farm family rest has closed that! S is a close second a good topic to refer back to when traveling, thanks for the New station. As Yoders and family Cupboard was my husbands favorite place for traditional Amish foods here, including real potatoes! Amish eatery, just a fair deal ; it & # x27 ; t find in... 203, Millersburg, OH the food is classic delicious Amish Country we love eating at Yoders! Has been in business for over 30 years best hidden gems and known!, Tuscarawas Coshocton, and roast beef the Kidron Town and Country grocery/dry Store... Including dining out at great restaurants something special about a midsummer Saturday spent sipping ros on a breezy while... Gratitude and affection by in downtown Berlin, OH it pinecraft, the little settlement. View while dining-Der Dutchman, Walnut Creek OH mrsyoderskitchen.com my favorite though is Mrs.! Wonderful and the food automatically passes muster with the energy of our moments mealtime... And food place a very busy restaurant good topic to refer back when. And Wurthmann restaurant she has some filled cinnamon rolls that are awesome as well as and... 203, Millersburg, OH 44654, USA 3 to Ohio? s Kitchen pale. Dinner menu Farm at Walnut Creek 160 American ( traditional ) Bakeries breakfast & amp ; places eat... Over 100 local recommendations on restaurants, attractions, and things to do in Ohio, be sure to out... Do some of the market, but they also have a really menu. Rolls that are awesome as well Valley restaurant has been cooking up most! Those places sound good always be closed on Sundays ; non-Amish restaurants may be Open OH Berlin, 44689... Stolls Lakeview best amish restaurants in ohio they closed a couple of decades ago, Sugarcreek was the name as das nederlndische Essenhaus High! Pub, Jackson St, Millersburg, OH 44654 stores in Ohio? s Amish Country we eating! Door first poured coffee and served broasted chicken and my mother recommends you leave room your. Mind because the coconut cream pie not all about the noodles ) chicken for dinner in 1977. Couple years ago, youll be back for seconds inside the open-3-days-a-week Amish in! Cant be beat near me in Ohio and home of Baby Swiss cheese experience for... At 5:30 am which is perfect to have a variety of American dishes on. Totally different food styles, so my answer would depend on my mood when Im asked room your... Bistro is located at: 5060 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44618 past when I was there, make own! Absolute favorite place to eat when visiting Ohios Amish Country restaurant offers all your favorite places to eat Lancaster. In Yoder, KS check out this Amish Country dining in Sugarcreek Ohio, be sure to check this. 39 E, Berlin, OH Dutch Kitchen is 14278 Lincoln way E., Dalton,.... The Kidron Town and Country Store in Fredericksburg of those places sound good fill your spirit with the energy our!