Happy Wednesday morning read: feminism and Game of Thrones. I’m not sure which one I like the best. I’m also not sure that I agree that Game of Thrones is as feminist a show as people seem think. It routinely, and much too frequently, depicts women as sex objects, only, and uses rape as a cynical plot point. Its setting is inarguably male-dominated, though it does portray women fighting against that social order. I asked elsewhere a while ago: is it portraying women in the conventional, objectifying, instrumental way to which we’ve grown accustomed, is it presenting a much more complex and informed critique of a woman’s lot in a deeply patriarchal society, or is it illustrating the limited (and always managed) power that any woman can hold in any society which is designed for, and run by, men?

I still haven’t answered that and, as you’ll see from here and here, it’s an answer about which I fluctuate very often.

Jordan Yerman presents his take in the Vancouver Observer. (Note: possible spoilers for S4/5 below.)

Game of Thrones Season Two brought us dragons, but Season Five may bring something to Westeros that its denizens will find even more wondrous and strange: feminism.

Despite its complex political and interpersonal landscape, Westeros as presented by HBO may well have sprung from the id of a fifteen-year-old boy who sees back-issues of National Geographic as a source of porn.

Not every character, though, functions to champion the notion that it’s a man’s, man’s, man’s world. Let’s start with the most staunch and terrifying feminist theorist in the Seven Kingdoms: Sandor “The Hound” Clegane. Yeah.

The theory and the practice

Early on, The Hound establishes himself as a buffer between Sansa Stark and Joffrey Baratheon’s douchey bullying. [The books, I’m told, suggest that the Hound has feelings for Sansa, but this is not pushed too hard in the HBO version; as you probably already know, I approach HBO’s Game of Thrones having not read the books.] After crossing paths with the Minstrels without Borders, The Hound and Arya become a compelling action-comedy duo as they ride toward sanctuary and payday, respectively.

Arya is kind of Sandor’s hostage, kind of his student, kind of his friend, even though she has added his name to her ever-growing Shit List. Still, The Hound sees potential in Arya, since she’s from a historically badass family and clearly wants to avenge her father’s death. This is where The Hound’s feminism really kicks in.

The Hound repeatedly points out Arya’s feminine behavior, but he separates that behavior from her sex. In the 1990 book Gender Trouble, feminist writer Judith Butler presented the theory of gender performativity, the TL;DR version of which is that gender is something that we do, rather than something we inherently are.

Furthermore, how we even understand the concept of womanhood is based upon a long-standing power imbalance. None of us has ever known a time when women’s rights were defined in any other way than in relation to male power.

So, is feminism the emphasis or de-emphasis of gender? Game of Thrones asks the audience this question a lot, whether or not the writers and show runners realize it.

Brienne of Tarth goes for the latter, but hardly anybody else in the Seven Kingdoms is on the same page. The Hound’s forward-thinking stance in feminism is quite casual. He doesn’t make a big thing about it, probably because he wouldn’t consider himself a feminist. That, however, does not prevent him from committing act after act of feminism, even if some of those acts are based in selfishness, but… baby steps.

In fact, The Hound would seem to be the only male feminist advocate in the Seven Kingdoms. Even though he uses the four-letter C-word liberally in front of Arya, The Hound doesn’t think twice about risking his freedom and his life to defend her from anyone who so much as looks at her funny. This tendency continues after any hope of a ransom has evaporated: what you think you’ll get a buck out of the Night’s Watch out of Castle Black? As Biggie once said, “Shit, forget it!”

In admonishing Arya for “fighting like a girl,” The Hound makes it clear that she is not her gender. He encourages her to reach her personal potential, even though she has stated quite unequivocally that she intends to use that potential to kill him.

Rest: Vancouver Observer.


p class="wordpresspost">(Orig. posted on feimineach.com)

The feminism of Game of Thrones